The Best Pizza & Italian on Hilton Head Island

Every pizza & italian pick below earned its spot — tasted by us, never sponsored.

Pizza at Local Pie BestBites Fave

Pizza

Local Pie · Coligny & South End · $

Classic wood-fired goodness
Chicago-Style Pan Pizza at Capri Pizza & Pasta BestBites Fave

Chicago-Style Pan Pizza

Capri Pizza & Pasta · Coligny & South End · $$$

A hybrid Chicago pizza with outstanding flavor
Thin Crust Pizza at Mangiamo’s BestBites Fave

Thin Crust Pizza

Mangiamo’s · North End · $$

Tasty thin crust pie at a shrine to Ohio State athletics
Stromboli at Frosty Frog BestBites Fave

Stromboli

Frosty Frog · Coligny & South End · $$

Surprise hit item at a big menu spot
Pizza at Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta House BestBites Fave

Pizza

Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta House · Shelter Cove · $$

Probably the best pizza on an island not known for its pizza

← Browse every bite