What to Order at Captain Woody’s
Coligny & South End · 3 bites we recommend — tasted in person, never sponsored.
Captain Woody’s started in 1982 with Woody Collins selling fish and shrimp off his trawler at Palmetto Bay Marina — the restaurant came later. It’s changed hands and addresses since, but the seafood focus stuck, and the patio still welcomes dogs.
BestBites Fave
Buffalo Triggerfish Sandwich
Captain Woody’s · Coligny & South End · $$
Triggerfish is hugely underrated, as is this sandy
BestBites Fave
Shrimp Chili
Captain Woody’s · Coligny & South End · $
Chili never tasted so good
BestBites Fave
BBQ Burger
Captain Woody’s · Coligny & South End · $
One of the best hamburgers on the island